In 2016, a chance meeting with the magnetic Mia Hines at Darby's wedding rocks mild-mannered book editor Marcus Watkins' world. As Marcus becomes increasingly infatuated with his new friend, his marriage with Emily is thrown for a loop.
As he overstays his welcome at his sister Ida's place, a reeling Marcus struggles to fill the gaping hole left by his divorce. After clashing with Mia, Marcus finally decides to wade back into the dating pool - with mixed results.
After an unexpected romp with an old flame, Marcus (accidentally) finds himself with a date to his parents' anniversary party in Michigan. While her brother's relationship wounds are reopened, Ida finds herself continuously annoyed by her girlfriend, Keiko.
Marcus rushes headfirst into a relationship with playwright Ola, but soon finds himself having trouble "performing."
While juggling a causal relationship with an older woman, Marcus is forced to deal with his "daddy issues" - and some shocking news.
Marcus reconnects with Mia as he experiences complex emotions in the wake of Becca's big reveal.
Anna Kendrick
Darby
Zoë Chao
Sara
Peter Vack
Jim
Sasha Compère
Mallory
Scoot McNairy
Bradley