Mary K. Devault

Jay agrees to sub in on Cam’s bowling team for the finals but Cam was not fully upfront about it being an all gay league, which puts Jay in a precarious position. Phil and Claire have a surprisingly good time with unlikely dinner companions, their neighbors Ronnie and Amber, and Gloria and Mitch agree to go clubbing with Haley to prove they’re still young and fun but they didn’t anticipate the pre-party portion of the night.

Katherine is unable to keep some of her secrets; Susan's young, attractive cousin reveals more than expected; a surprise wedding ceremony has its share of secrets.

The BAU team opens an investigation when a man who fully believes he's Dr. Tara Lewis' brother arrives in town, knowing everything about her and her family, and she is unable to make contact with her real sibling.

As Linette (Cybill Shepherd) presses Katie to participate in an upcoming beauty pageant, Riley (Jennifer Love Hewitt) questions her growing feelings for Evan (Colin Egglesfield) after her daughter catches them kissing.

Audrey (Megyn Price) attends her high school reunion in Nebraska with Jeff (Patrick Warburton) in hopes to show her classmates she is no longer a loser and has made it in the big city. Not one to spend time alone, Russell (David Spade) crashes Timmy's (Adhir Kalyan) dinner party, bumping into invited guests Jennifer (Bianca Kajlich) and Adam (Oliver Hudson).