Jim plans a surprise party for Cheryl's birthday, but cancels it when Dana spills the beans; to make it up to him, Cheryl plans a party for him... but he's too busy bowling to show up.
Jim has a run-in with an old friend from his wild and crazy days who is now a cop; Jim sets out to prove he's still the same guy by staying out all night and partying but this has bad consequences for both of them.