Chad is filming a movie about his life, and he has cast Selena Gomez to play Sonny. While researching the part, Selena realizes Sonny and Chad have feelings for each other and spends the episode trying to help them overcome their denial.
Chad alerts the So Random! cast that he has been given his own show called Celebrity Practical Jok'd. The group gets overly paranoid that one of them will join Chad to set up a prank and begin setting pranks for each other.
Tawni falls for a down-to-earth guy, Hayden, and relies on Sonny to help her seem like his type. Sonny arranges courtside tickets for a basketball game for them, but ends up kissing Hayden because of the 'Kiss Cam.'
Chad Dylan Cooper forces the So Random! cast out of their Prop House in order to make a Mackenzie Falls meditation room. While reflecting on their props, the cast remember the characters and sketches they created in the Prop House.