Jefferson Brown

Agent Howard visits Haven to question Audrey about her strange behavior as a local policewoman, but the interrogation is derailed when two of the town's criminals hijack Duke's boat with Howard, Audrey and Duke aboard.

The whole town is caught up in romance when Cassie helps Ben find an old film for him to show an opening night of the refurbished Middleton Theater – a classic love movie from the 30s: “How to Say, I Love You!” – which proves to be a very meaningful title. Meanwhile, Martha has overextended herself with the Middleton budget, and there is no money left in the extra expenditure account. When Grace discovers a benevolent fund that was forgotten about long ago, Martha is able to fulfill her promises to the town, with enough left over to makeover the theater marquee - all thanks to Grace, though she refuses to take any of the credit. Martha says she’s becoming more like her mother every day, which is the best compliment Grace can think of.

The Middleton Merriwick is still not in bloom, and the effects are being felt around town – especially with the Merriwick women. An old friend and colleague of Abigail’s checks into Grey House claiming to want a relationship with her, only Abigail discovers he is trying to deceive her into signing away her stake in the company they founded together. And with an assist from Cassie, Ben stumbles upon the old Middleton Theater and is motivated to get the place running again.

The team locks down in the office to isolate and destroy a murderous demon that followed them home.

In the aftermath of the night’s traumatic events, Andy and Dov try to pull themselves together at an all-night diner, but are caught off-duty and off-guard in a volatile diner hold-up. Meanwhile, the weary officers at 15 Division struggle to contain the evening’s collateral damage under the watchful eye of a tough new Inspector.