Captain Deuce Stevens has a run-in with April during an office visit with Finn.
Andy's new metal detector uncovers Jim's long-lost wedding ring, which causes headaches for Jim, because he bought a fake wedding ring as a replacement a long time ago so Cheryl wouldn't notice he lost it.
Jim fails to teach his son how to play softball properly; Andy's ghost from the future shows him that Kyle turns out as a loser, so Jim tries to change his son's future, but only makes things worse.
Jim toughens up his daughter's basketball team and soon turns them from sweet and peaceful to angry and aggressive.
With Cheryl's pregnancy forcing her to bed rest, Jim is left in charge to run Gracie's birthday party; Jim changes birthday party plans by staging a game of Capture the Flag.