When Jeff (Patrick Warburton) gives Audrey (Megyn Price) tickets to a musical, she could not be more enthused. However while enjoying her favorite pastime, she spots a familiar, Russell (David Spade), at the same venue. Meanwhile, Jennifer (Bianca Kajlich) decides that Adam (Oliver Hudson) needs dance lessons for their pending nuptials, but it turns out that Jennifer is the one who has two left feet.
Jeff (Patrick Warburton) plans a trip to Atlantic City for his friend?s bachelor party on the same weekend Audrey (Megyn Price) has family coming to visit. When Jeff learns the wedding has been called off, he and Russell (David Spade) still decide to go to Atlantic City for a ?guys? weekend, inviting Timmy (Adhir Kalyan) and Adam (Oliver Hudson) to join. In the meantime, Audrey?s family cancels their visit and she secretly plans a spa weekend in Atlantic City with Jennifer (Bianca Kajlich) unbeknownst to Jeff. Things get sticky when Audrey discovers the bachelor party has been cancelled and she starts a game of revenge to ruin Jeff?s weekend with the guys.
When Audrey (Megyn Pierce) becomes jealous of a pregnant co-worker, she inadvertently convinces her colleagues that she has a bundle of joy on the way too. Meanwhile, Jennifer (Bianca Kajlich) and Adam (Oliver Hudson) get a surprise Amish visitor Toby (Guest Star: Jake Thomas) who is a little unaccustomed to his new urban surroundings. Russell (David Spade) quickly takes it upon himself to show Toby around town and exposes him his so called "fabulous bachelor lifestyle." The end result is unbelievable.
Russell (David Spade) reluctantly agrees to host a photo shoot in his apartment for Audrey's (Megyn Price) magazine, with the hope of landing a date with a hot model. Adam (Oliver Hudson) steps in to play the groom in Audrey's wedding-themed shoot, prompting him to make a decision about his own engagement. Meanwhile, Jeff (Patrick Warburton) and Jennifer (Bianca Kajlich) discover unexpected common interests with each other while searching for a birthday gift for Audrey.
Jeff (Patrick Warburton) accidentally injects himself with Audrey's (Megyn Price) hormones for her fertility treatments on the day that they are attending her new boss? party. Adam (Oliver Hudson) forgets that it is Jennifer?s (Bianca Kajlich) birthday but is saved when Jeff gives him tickets to a Ranger?s game that he cannot attend. Russell (David Spade) regrets taking Timmy (Adhir Kalyan) to the hockey game, when his allegiance to the opposing team gets out of control.
