Jake and Amy investigate a difficult "he said, she said" case. Holt becomes suspicious after learning his lifelong arch nemesis died in a prison transport accident.
Brad (Damon Wayans, Jr.) looks to avoid dinner with Jane’s (Eliza Coupe) college ex, until he learns that it’s a woman. Dave (Zachary Knighton) and Alex (Elisha Cuthbert) are smitten with Max’s (Adam Pally) mysterious new roommate; Penny (Casey Wilson) joins her new boyfriend’s circle of friends.
When a juror dies during Susan's first big trial as lead attorney, Margaret and Todd work to exonerate Amy, a juror from the same trial suspected of the murder. Also, Margaret's sister Patty is in town and sparks fly between Todd and Amy.
When Grayson complains that his life is like "Groundhog Day," Jules asks for that to be the theme of her bachelorette party; Grayson convinces Jules to elope, but their friends tag along.
Jules has a hurricane party at her house when a storm blows into town; Travis decides to make a play for Laurie.