Alan and Walden have a meeting with an adoption social worker (guest star Maggie Lawson) that hinges on them being convincing as a loving couple. Scrambling to make the beach house presentable, their plans are put in jeopardy when Lyndsey (recurring guest star Courtney Thorne-Smith) returns after 60 days in rehab.
Walden and Alan meet a birth mother who's considering them to adopt her baby. Maggie Lawson guest stars as a social worker helping Walden and Alan adopt a child.
Alden and Cotton find themselves face-to-face with a real witch. Mary forges a solution to the discord within the coven.